2021 Final East vs. West PGF All Americans teams were announced and will air July 31 at 6:30 PM PT on ESPNU.
West
| Position | First Name | Last Name | City | State | College | Travel Ball Team |
| 1B/3B | Grace | Keene | Santa Clarita | CA | Tennessee | So Cal Choppers |
| 1B/3B | McKenna | Gibson | Valencia | CA | Tennessee | Athletics Mercado |
| 3B/1B | Breanna | Hayward | Tucson | AZ | Texas Tech | Oro Valley Suncats |
| 3B | Maddie | Moore | Loomis | CA | Clemson | Lady Magic |
| C/1B | Lici | Campbell | Vallejo | CA | Oregon St. | Lady Magic |
| C | Hannah | Slike | Chula Vista | CA | Boston College | So Cal Athletics |
| C | Sophia | Nugent | Seal Beach | CA | Oklahoma | Firecrackers Rico |
| Inf | Spencer | Prigge | Phoenix | AZ | Arkansas | Oro Valley Suncats |
| Inf | Ella | Nadeau | Highland | CA | Stanford | CA Cruisers Sievers |
| Inf | Rylee | Holtorf | Phoenix | AZ | Washington | AZ Storm Mathis |
| Inf | Taylor | Stephens | Lynwood | CA | UCLA | Firecrackers TJ |
| Inf | Cydney | Sanders | San Marcos | CA | ASU | Corona Angels |
| OF | Taylor | Ebbs | Keizer | OR | Kentucky | NW Bullets |
| OF | Paige | Dimler | Vista | CA | Arizona | Breakers Labs |
| OF | Olivia | Silvestre | San Ramon | CA | Cal | So Cal Athletics |
| OF | Tai | Wilson | Fairfield | CA | Seattle | Sorcerers Williams |
| OF/UT | Isabella | Fishman | Cypress | CA | James Madison | USA Athletics Gold |
| P | Dee Dee | Hernandez | La Crescenta | CA | San Diego St. | Panthers Gold |
| P | Stevie | Hansen | Norco | CA | Oregon | Athletics Mercado |
| P | Nicola | Simpson | Seattle | WA | Tennessee | WA Ladyhawks Miller |
East
| Position | First Name | Last Name | City | State | College | Travel Ball Team |
| 1B/C | Lyndi Rae | Davis | Calhoun | GA | Georgia | Atlanta Vipers Gold Holbrook |
| 1B/UT | Sarah | Stone | Bedford | IN | Kentucky | Beverly Bandits Demarini Moran |
| C | Kali | Decker | Lake Mary | FL | Florida | GA Impact Premier Lewis |
| C/UT | Katie | Cimusz | Humble | TX | Texas | Hotshots Premier Dumezich |
| C | Giulia | Desiderio | Hudson | FL | South Carolina | Intensity KOD |
| MI | Grace | Nieto | Famington Hills | MI | Northwestern | Beverly Bandits Premier Skeens |
| SS | Jada | Baker | Longwood | FL | Duke | Lady Dukes Lamar Gold |
| Inf | Easton | Lotus | New Lenox | IL | Louisville | Beverly Bandits Premier Skeens |
| Inf | Nelia | Peralta | Wellington | FL | Auburn | Birmingham Thunderbolts Premier |
| Inf/P | Annabelle | Widra | Hoover | AL | Michigan | Birmingham Thunderbolts Premier |
| Inf | Megan | Bloodworth | Cordele | GA | Alabama | Atlanta Vipers Gold Holcrook |
| Inf | Brooke | Barnard | Palm Beach Gardens | FL | Ole Miss | Intensity KOD |
| OF | McKenzie | Redoutey | Franklin | NC | LSU | GA Impact Premier Lewis |
| OF | Dallis | Goodnight | Dacula | GA | Alabama | GA Impact Premier Lewis |
| OF | Maddie | Snider | Columbia | MO | Missouri | Select Fastpitch |
| OF | Jordan | Stephens | Tampa | FL | Alabama | Tampa Mustangs TJ |
| OF | Darien | McDonough | Lincoln | RI | Boston College | Rhode Island Thunder Lotti |
| P | Samantha | Landry | Mont Bevieu | TX | Louisiana LLU | Hotshots Premier Dumezich |
| P | Jordyn | Bahl | Papillion | NE | Okalahoma | Nebraska Gold |
| P | Allison | Benning | Lake Elmo | MN | Oregon | Top Gun National |